Reflections
Finding Authenticity: What It Means to Be Yourself as You Change
By Vika
·"Be authentic. Be yourself." It is one of the most common pieces of advice women receive, and I have come to think it is also one of the most misunderstood. It sounds wonderful. It fits nicely on a coffee mug. But what does it mean?
When I was a girl in the Soviet Union, I fell in love with Texas. Not the real Texas, which I had never seen, but the one in Mayne Reid's The Headless Horseman: vast landscapes, danger, adventure, freedom, and, most important to my teenage imagination, cowboys. I spent countless hours imagining myself there. Then, when I was sixteen, my parents announced that we were leaving the Soviet Union and moving to Houston. Houston, Texas. Talk about manifesting.
I did not speak English and did not know a single person in Texas, and none of that seemed to matter. I was moving to the place I had been dreaming about. Reality had other plans. It took four months of refugee travel through Austria and Italy before we reached Houston, and the Texas waiting for me bore remarkably little resemblance to the one Mayne Reid had promised.
I had come from Leningrad, now St. Petersburg, a beautiful, compact European city where people walked and took public transportation. Houston was enormous and diverse, and I learned quickly that living there without a car required a certain level of determination. I rode public transportation that first year. It did not figure prominently in my cowboy fantasy.
The adjustment was hard. The language, the culture, the people, and the expectations were all unfamiliar. But slowly I learned English, got a car, and started college, and then something happened: America became exciting. My life seemed to overflow with possibility. I wanted to learn everything, meet everyone, and go everywhere. If you had met me my freshman year, you would have found a bright-eyed young woman eager to tell you how her family had left everything behind for the chance at freedom in a new world. I loved that girl, and sometimes I miss her.
More than thirty years later, after raising children and practicing law for decades, the woman in the mirror is considerably more complicated. She has learned diplomacy, responsibility, and restraint. She knows when to speak and when silence is wiser, and she understands that being right and being effective are not always the same thing. Along the way she collected identities almost without noticing: mother, wife, attorney, advisor, athlete, friend. Each came with expectations, and at some point I began to wonder where, underneath all of them, I had gone.
Most women I know move among several identities every day. Family, work, friendships, and society all place expectations on us, and we learn which parts of ourselves are welcome in which rooms. Whether we admit it or not, we adjust. We soften an opinion, avoid a confrontation, smile when we are not particularly interested in smiling, and say the diplomatic thing instead of the thing passing through our minds. Does that make us inauthentic?
I used to think so. I believed authenticity required complete transparency, that being authentic meant expressing your inner self regardless of what anyone thought. I no longer believe that, and I am not convinced complete authenticity would make any of us pleasant to live with. Imagine practicing radical authenticity with your boss on a bad day, or with your spouse, or your children, or the person taking forever in front of you at airport security. Some thoughts deserve to remain authentic, private thoughts.
Part of the problem is that we treat authenticity as though each of us contains one permanent, pristine version of ourselves, and our job is to dig her out. I do not think she exists. The girl I was at sixteen was authentic. So was the young woman starting college in Houston, the new lawyer, the young mother, and the woman I am today. They are not the same person, and they should not be.
Identity keeps changing. We live, learn, and develop, and a friend once reminded me that although we live through constant change, we often forget to "allow the change" to take place within us. I think about that often. Every once in a while I reread things I wrote when I was younger, and I used to cringe. Did I write that? Apparently I did. Somewhere along the way I stopped being embarrassed by my younger self and began to love her. She was doing the best she could with what she knew at the time, the same as I am now.
Maybe that is what authenticity means to me today: accepting the person I used to be as fully as the person I have become. Finding authenticity does not mean preserving ourselves as we once were; growth would be impossible if it did. It means letting our experiences change us without losing the ability to recognize what matters to us underneath all that change.
Over time I have come to think authenticity has two sides. External authenticity is the self we show the world, shaped by our responsibilities, relationships, environment, and experiences. Internal authenticity is the quieter part of us that knows what we believe, what matters, and who we are becoming. I may choose to limit how much of a feeling I express in a given moment, but I work hard to keep that internal authenticity intact.
That may be the balance I have been looking for: to move through the world with kindness, mindfulness, and understanding without letting the world define me; to accept the girl I used to be without wishing to become her again; to accept the woman I am today without apologizing for how much she has changed; and to leave enough room for whoever comes next.
The girl in Leningrad reading The Headless Horseman could never have imagined the life waiting for her. She dreamed about Texas and cowboys, and somehow she found her way there. Maybe authenticity works the same way. We never completely arrive; we keep finding our way back to ourselves. So how do you know when you are being authentic? Maybe the better question is whether you still recognize yourself as you change.
Reflections